Dogs bite. Some dogs don't let go.  |  DogsBite.org
 
 
About Us  |  DonateDonate now!
 
 
DogsBite logo   Over 150 dog breeds populate the US. Studies show that two breeds account for nearly 70% of bites that end in death and serious injury. We must regulate these breeds or risk the safety of our families and pets.
 
 

Dogs Bite Blog ::

browse:   comments,    sticky,     fatal attacks,    victims of attacks,    senior attacks,    postal attacks,    dog laws,    dogfighting,    pit bull owners,    police shootings,    animal groups,    roaming dogs,    horse attacks,    livestock attacks,    pet attacks,    family dog attacks,    trials

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Bill Stops Convicted Drug Dealers from Owning Dogs Over 20lbs

The "Over 20lb" Pit Advocate Bull
New York - The State of New York has passed a bill that prohibits anyone convicted of selling or possessing a controlled substance within the past five years from having a dog that is trained to attack or be vicious. The bill vaguely defines this type of dog as weighing over 20lbs and has either been trained to attack other people or has exhibited a vicious disposition or propensity.
Other than pit bulls, what kind of dogs to drug dealers own? And exactly how does one prove in court the last two aspects?
This is a "come from behind" law. After police have entered a home to serve a warrant and witnessed the dog acting "vicious," the dog owner (assuming he or she already has a drug conviction) will be penalized. The law is designed to help protect police officers from "repeat" drug offenders. It is unclear how the law will protect common citizens. Casting a wide net with substantial vagueness does not effectively address the pit bull-criminality problem.

No stamp of approval from DogsBite.org. It's clear Senator Bill Larkin has been up to his ears in pro-pit bull lobbyists. Anytime you hear the phrase, "any dog over 20lbs" is a good indicator the bill's original intention was to target pit bulls, but got watered down by pit advocates. A good defense attorney will tear this law to pieces.

Labels:

posted by bitbypit  |  permalink  |   6 comments   |   AddThis Social Bookmark Button   |  
 

6 comments:

Even though keeping Pit Bulls out of the hands of drugs dealers is a good thing for law and order, as well as the dogs themselves, the Pit Bull community will howl like screech monkees over this.

They'll do and say anything to keep the sale of these dogs plentiful and unregulated.

by Anonymous Anonymous 6/20/2008 2:16 AM  |  Flag as abusive  

ALL felons should be restricted from not only pit bulls but also ALL large potentially dangerous dogs.


This law is better than nothing.

by Anonymous Anonymous 6/20/2008 12:06 PM  |  Flag as abusive  

Assuming it can stand up in court anonymous. By not specifying a breed -- a very obvious breed used by drug dealers -- that has a well-known history of documented violence and use by criminal offenders, prosecutors stand the risk of getting the charges thrown out.
by Anonymous Trigger 6/20/2008 12:30 PM  |  Flag as abusive  

The law should pour over into parole and probation stipulations, providing these departments are made aware. I believe they have a free hand to stipulate, "may not own a dog, (period)" without elaboration or specificity, but this could vary between jurisdictions. It would keep things simple to add the stipulation to the hard copy of automatic violations. At the very least, it gives police the ability to violate parolees in possession on sight.

Of course, I can hear it from here. "No-no, man! Ain't my dawg, bro. Get off me!" snap... tck-tck-tck-tck-tck-tck (sound of taser)

by Anonymous Anonymous 6/20/2008 5:15 PM  |  Flag as abusive  

There is absolutely no evidence at all that "any" dog over 20lbs can be trained to be vicious. There is a WORLD of evidence that "any" pit bull can be trained to be vicious. One good lawyer will chuck this law out the window.
by Anonymous Steelhead 6/21/2008 10:13 AM  |  Flag as abusive  

The pit bull lobby loves the fact that other, safer breeds have to be overregulated for these laws to be considered "fair".
by Anonymous Anonymous 6/24/2008 3:30 AM  |  Flag as abusive  

Post a Comment »

 

 
special features More »
bar
Charlotte Blevins Coverage of the Omaha Pit Bull Attack
DogsBite.org »
Charlotte Blevins Report: Dog Attacks on Livestock & Horses
DogsBite.org »
recent posts  
bar
recent archives  
bar
victim voices More »
bar
quote symbol quote symbol
recommended book:
On Behalf of Innocents: A True Story of a Mission, Faith, and a Promise Fulfilled
Following a life-threatening attack by vicious dogs, author Caress Garten reflects upon the power of individuals to change the law.
shop Now

 

 
 
DogsBite.org:  dogsbite blog  |  bite statistics  |  dangerous dogs  |  legislating dogs  |  victim realities  |  staying safe  |  donateDonate now!